Asphalt vs Metal Roofs: Best Choice for Tennessee Homes

Compare asphalt vs metal roofs for Tennessee homes. Discover costs, durability, energy savings, and expert tips to choose the perfect roof for your property.

Understanding Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Choosing between asphalt vs metal roofs is one of the most important decisions for Tennessee homeowners. Both materials offer strong protection, but they differ in cost, longevity, and efficiency. Understanding these differences early ensures a smart investment for your home.

Why the Choice Matters for Tennessee Homes

Tennessee’s climate combines heat, humidity, and seasonal storms. As a result, your roof must handle fluctuating conditions without compromising comfort or energy efficiency.

Key reasons this decision matters:

  • Climate affects long-term roof performance

  • Maintenance and replacement frequency vary

  • Energy costs depend on material type

  • Aesthetic differences impact resale value

👉 Reference: Energy.gov – Roofing and Climate

Overview of Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Both roofing systems have evolved with modern technology. Asphalt roofs are known for affordability and traditional appearance, while metal roofs excel in durability and eco-friendliness.

Quick comparison highlights:

  • Asphalt roofs: low upfront cost, wide color range

  • Metal roofs: higher initial investment, longer lifespan

  • Both offer strong protection when installed professionally

👉 Reference: NRCA – Roofing Materials Guide

How to Evaluate the Right Option

Selecting between asphalt vs metal roofs involves balancing short-term savings with long-term value. Homeowners should consider climate, budget, and maintenance goals before choosing.

Evaluation checklist:

  • Review lifespan and warranty options

  • Assess appearance with your home’s design

  • Compare noise resistance and energy performance

  • Consult certified local contractors before deciding

👉 Reference: Consumer Reports – Roofing Buying Guide

Key Factors for Concrete Decisions

Why these factors matter for your property’s long-term value.

Home Protection

Why It’s Important: Stops leaks, mold, and weather damage
Long-Term Benefit: Safe, comfortable living space

Cost Savings

Why It’s Important: Avoids repeated repairs and high bills
Long-Term Benefit: More affordable in the long run

Repair vs. Replacement

Why It’s Important: Defines when repairs no longer work
Long-Term Benefit: Smarter investment decision

Smart choices today mean stronger, longer-lasting concrete tomorrow!

The Basics of Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Before comparing performance or cost, it’s essential to understand what makes asphalt vs metal roofs distinct. Each material has unique properties that influence installation, durability, and appearance.

What Are Asphalt Roofs?

Asphalt roofs remain the most popular choice in the U.S. due to their affordability and design flexibility. They consist of fiberglass mats coated with asphalt and mineral granules, which provide waterproof protection and visual appeal.

Main features include:

  • Lightweight and easy to install

  • Variety of colors and textures

  • Effective insulation against moderate temperatures

  • Economical for homeowners on a budget

However, they can degrade faster under constant sun exposure or heavy rain. Still, with proper maintenance, asphalt roofing can last up to 25 years.

👉 Reference: Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association

What Are Metal Roofs?

Metal roofs have gained popularity for their superior strength and energy efficiency. Typically made from aluminum, steel, or copper panels, they offer exceptional weather resistance and longevity.

Key advantages of metal roofs:

  • Lifespan of 40–70 years

  • Reflects sunlight, reducing energy bills

  • Minimal maintenance required

  • Fire-resistant and environmentally friendly

In addition, modern coatings make metal roofs quieter and available in various styles that mimic shingles or tiles.

👉 Reference: Metal Roofing Alliance

Comparing Installation Processes

When it comes to asphalt vs metal roofs, installation time and technique differ significantly. Asphalt shingles are nailed directly to roof decking, while metal panels require interlocking systems and specialized fasteners.

Installation differences:

  • Asphalt: Faster setup, ideal for quick replacements

  • Metal: Precision-based process, takes longer but lasts decades

  • Both: Require professional installation for warranty validation

Professional installation ensures structural safety and proper sealing, which prevents leaks and wind damage.

👉 Reference: HomeAdvisor – Roof Installation Methods

Lifespan and Warranty Basics

Longevity is one of the biggest distinctions in the asphalt vs metal roofs debate. While asphalt shingles provide solid performance for 15–25 years, metal roofing often doubles or triples that lifespan.

Typical warranties:

  • Asphalt: 15–30 years, depending on brand and maintenance

  • Metal: 40–50 years or more, often transferable

  • Extended warranties available through certified installers

Ultimately, lifespan reflects both the material’s quality and the skill of installation.

Basics of Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Feature Asphalt Roofs Metal Roofs
Average Lifespan 15–25 years 40–70 years
Material Composition Fiberglass, asphalt, granules Steel, aluminum, copper
Installation Time 1–3 days 3–7 days
Maintenance Level Moderate Low
Cost Efficiency Budget-friendly Long-term investment

Comparing Durability in Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

When it comes to longevity and strength, asphalt vs metal roofs perform very differently. Durability often determines the long-term value of your investment, especially in Tennessee, where roofs face high humidity, strong winds, and heavy rainfall.

How Weather Affects Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Tennessee’s climate puts any roof to the test. Asphalt shingles can crack or lose granules in high heat, while metal panels resist expansion and remain stable in temperature fluctuations.

Weather impact summary:

  • Asphalt roofs: Can soften under UV exposure and lose adhesion over time

  • Metal roofs: Expand slightly with heat but retain structural integrity

  • Both: Benefit from professional sealing and regular inspection

Moreover, roofs installed with proper underlayment perform better against sudden storms and leaks.

👉 Reference: National Weather Service – Climate Data Tennessee

Resistance to Impact and Hail Damage

Durability also depends on resistance to impact. Asphalt shingles can suffer dents and cracks from hail or falling branches, while metal roofs usually deflect such impacts.

Impact resistance factors:

  • Metal roofs often receive a Class 4 rating, the highest in roofing strength tests

  • Asphalt roofs with thicker layers can reach Class 3, offering moderate protection

  • Proper installation improves resistance in both materials

In addition, modern metal coatings prevent corrosion and extend roof life after severe weather events.

👉 Reference: Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety

Wind and Storm Durability

High winds frequently hit East Tennessee, making wind resistance essential. Asphalt vs metal roofs differ greatly in this aspect.

Wind performance:

  • Asphalt shingles: Can lift or blow off if improperly nailed

  • Metal roofs: Interlocking panels withstand gusts up to 140 mph

  • Both: Require professional fastening systems to ensure stability

Furthermore, correct attic ventilation reduces pressure beneath the roof, preventing uplift during storms.

👉 Reference: FEMA – Wind Resistant Construction

Long-Term Durability and Maintenance

Over time, durability also depends on upkeep. While both materials can last decades, maintenance frequency varies greatly.

Durability comparison over time:

  • Asphalt roofs: 15–25 years with regular inspections

  • Metal roofs: 40–70 years with minimal care

  • Proper cleaning and debris removal extend both lifespans

In conclusion, metal clearly outperforms asphalt in long-term resilience, but asphalt remains a reliable choice for cost-effective short-term solutions.

Durability in Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

How each roofing type performs under various durability factors.

Weather Resistance

Asphalt Roofs: Moderate
Metal Roofs: Excellent

Hail & Impact Resistance

Asphalt Roofs: Moderate (Class 3)
Metal Roofs: High (Class 4)

Wind Resistance

Asphalt Roofs: Up to 110 mph
Metal Roofs: Up to 140 mph

Lifespan

Asphalt Roofs: 15–25 years
Metal Roofs: 40–70 years

Maintenance Frequency

Asphalt Roofs: Regular inspections required
Metal Roofs: Low maintenance

📊 Choosing the right roof means balancing durability, cost, and care!

Cost Comparison – Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

When choosing between asphalt vs metal roofs, cost is often the first factor homeowners consider. While asphalt appears more affordable upfront, metal roofing delivers better long-term value through durability and reduced maintenance expenses.

Initial Installation Costs

The biggest difference in asphalt vs metal roofs is the installation price. Asphalt is cheaper to produce and easier to install, while metal requires more specialized labor and materials.

Average installation costs:

  • Asphalt roofs: $4 to $7 per square foot

  • Metal roofs: $8 to $14 per square foot

  • Prices vary depending on pitch, complexity, and material thickness

Although the initial cost is higher for metal, the return on investment often balances out over time due to longevity and efficiency.

👉 Reference: HomeAdvisor – Roof Cost Guide

Long-Term Maintenance and Repair Costs

Cost analysis doesn’t stop at installation. Maintenance plays a big role in lifetime expenses.

Maintenance comparison:

  • Asphalt roofs need regular inspections, resealing, and occasional shingle replacement

  • Metal roofs require minimal maintenance and are less prone to leaks or cracks

  • Over 30 years, homeowners may spend twice as much maintaining asphalt compared to metal

In addition, metal roofing resists mold and pest damage, reducing unexpected costs.

👉 Reference: Angi – Roof Maintenance Costs

Energy Savings and Efficiency Value

One key advantage of asphalt vs metal roofs lies in energy performance. Metal reflects heat effectively, lowering summer cooling bills. Asphalt absorbs heat, which can increase indoor temperatures.

Estimated energy impacts:

  • Metal roofs can cut energy costs by up to 25% annually

  • Asphalt roofs may retain heat, raising air-conditioning usage

  • Reflective coatings further enhance savings for metal systems

These efficiency benefits add long-term value to metal roofing investments.

👉 Reference: Energy Star – Roofing Materials

Total Lifetime Value

When comparing total lifetime cost, metal roofing typically outperforms asphalt. Although it requires a higher initial investment, it lasts two to three times longer and often improves property resale value.

Lifetime value summary:

  • Asphalt: Lower entry cost, higher maintenance, shorter lifespan

  • Metal: Higher upfront cost, lower upkeep, superior durability

  • Homeowners looking for long-term savings often choose metal roofing

Ultimately, the better option depends on budget and long-term goals, but the total cost of ownership clearly favors metal.

Cost Comparison: Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Cost Factor Asphalt Roofs Metal Roofs
Installation Cost $4–$7 per sq. ft. $8–$14 per sq. ft.
Maintenance Frequency Regular (annual or bi-annual) Minimal
Energy Savings Low High (up to 25%)
Average Lifespan 15–25 years 40–70 years
Long-Term Value Moderate Excellent

Energy Efficiency – Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Energy efficiency plays a vital role when deciding between asphalt vs metal roofs. The right material can reduce utility costs, improve comfort, and even support eco-friendly living. In Tennessee’s hot summers and cool winters, efficient roofing systems make a noticeable difference in monthly energy bills.

How Asphalt vs Metal Roofs Affect Home Temperature

Roofing materials directly influence how heat moves in and out of your home. Asphalt absorbs heat, making attics warmer during summer, while metal reflects sunlight to maintain cooler temperatures.

Performance highlights:

  • Asphalt roofs: Retain heat and may increase cooling needs

  • Metal roofs: Reflect up to 70% of solar energy

  • Both: Benefit from adequate attic insulation and ventilation

Therefore, metal roofing provides better thermal control and helps HVAC systems work less.

👉 Reference: Energy.gov – Heat Reflection in Roofing

Seasonal Energy Performance

Tennessee’s changing weather exposes each roof type to different challenges. During summer, reflective metal surfaces perform better, while asphalt roofs can absorb extra heat. In winter, both roofs retain warmth if insulated correctly.

Seasonal impacts:

  • Summer: Metal roofs reduce air-conditioning costs

  • Winter: Insulated asphalt roofs retain indoor heat

  • Year-round: Ventilation and attic sealing improve efficiency in both

In addition, reflective metal coatings maintain performance even under intense sunlight.

👉 Reference: Cool Roof Rating Council

Environmental Benefits of Energy-Efficient Roofs

Energy efficiency also contributes to environmental sustainability. Since metal roofs last longer and are recyclable, they minimize waste and energy consumption.

Eco-benefits comparison:

  • Asphalt: Often ends up in landfills after 20–25 years

  • Metal: Fully recyclable, reduces carbon footprint

  • Energy-efficient roofing cuts household emissions overall

Consequently, choosing a reflective metal roof can support both your wallet and the environment.

👉 Reference: EPA – Energy Efficiency and Recycling

Insulation and Ventilation Tips for Maximum Efficiency

Regardless of the chosen material, insulation and ventilation are key. Proper airflow prevents moisture buildup and maintains stable indoor temperatures year-round.

Efficiency tips:

  • Use radiant barriers in attics

  • Add roof vents to enhance circulation

  • Seal gaps around ducts and chimneys

  • Schedule professional inspections annually

When installed correctly, both asphalt vs metal roofs can achieve impressive energy savings over time.

Energy Efficiency Comparison: Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

How each roof type performs when it comes to energy-saving potential.

Heat Reflection

Asphalt Roofs: Low (absorbs heat)
Metal Roofs: High (reflects up to 70%)

Cooling Efficiency

Asphalt Roofs: Moderate
Metal Roofs: Excellent

Winter Insulation

Asphalt Roofs: Good with proper attic insulation
Metal Roofs: Good

Environmental Impact

Asphalt Roofs: Limited recyclability
Metal Roofs: Fully recyclable, eco-friendly

Energy Savings Potential

Asphalt Roofs: Up to 10%
Metal Roofs: Up to 25% or more

🌞 Smart roofing choices impact your energy bills and the planet!

Maintenance and Longevity – Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Maintenance is one of the biggest factors when comparing asphalt vs metal roofs. Proper care determines how long each roof will last, how much it will cost over time, and how well it protects your home from Tennessee’s unpredictable weather.

Maintenance Requirements for Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Maintenance needs vary widely between the two materials. Asphalt roofs require more attention, while metal roofs demand less frequent servicing.

Routine tasks for each:

  • Asphalt roofs: Inspect for curled shingles, algae, or missing granules every season

  • Metal roofs: Check fasteners, joints, and coatings once or twice a year

  • Both: Keep gutters clear and remove debris after storms

In addition, scheduling professional inspections helps detect early signs of wear before costly repairs appear.

👉 Reference: Angi – Roof Maintenance Tips

Lifespan Comparison

The lifespan difference between asphalt vs metal roofs is significant. Asphalt typically lasts 15–25 years, while metal can last over 50 years with minimal upkeep.

Longevity factors:

  • Asphalt wears faster under UV exposure

  • Metal resists rust with modern coatings

  • Both last longer with proper attic ventilation

Therefore, homeowners seeking long-term value often prefer metal despite the higher upfront investment.

👉 Reference: Forbes Home – Roof Lifespan Guide

Common Issues That Affect Roof Longevity

Regardless of material, certain issues can shorten a roof’s lifespan. Weather, poor installation, and neglect are the main culprits.

Frequent problems:

  • Improper ventilation leading to trapped moisture

  • Clogged gutters causing water pooling

  • Neglected minor repairs turning into leaks

  • Moss or debris buildup weakening materials

However, regular maintenance and quick repairs prevent premature failure for both roof types.

👉 Reference: NRCA – Roof Care and Maintenance

Tips to Maximize Longevity

Homeowners can easily extend the life of their asphalt vs metal roofs by following consistent maintenance routines. Preventive care ensures protection and preserves roof aesthetics for decades.

Longevity best practices:

  • Schedule bi-annual professional inspections

  • Clean gutters and valleys regularly

  • Remove branches and debris after storms

  • Apply protective coatings when recommended

Ultimately, consistent care saves money, prevents leaks, and keeps your home looking its best year-round.

Maintenance & Longevity: Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Category Asphalt Roofs Metal Roofs
Lifespan 15–25 years 40–70 years
Maintenance Frequency Quarterly or seasonal Once or twice yearly
Common Issues Granule loss, leaks, curling Loose fasteners, coating wear
Maintenance Cost Range $300–$600 per year $150–$300 per year
Longevity Improvement Regular cleaning, attic ventilation Annual inspections, debris removal

Aesthetic Appeal – Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Curb appeal matters more than most homeowners realize. The look of your roof influences property value, first impressions, and even how large or warm a home feels. Comparing asphalt vs metal roofs, both offer unique visual advantages that can complement Tennessee’s diverse architectural styles.

Design Versatility in Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

One reason homeowners often choose asphalt roofs is design variety. Asphalt shingles come in many colors, textures, and shapes, making them ideal for both modern and traditional homes. However, metal roofing has evolved far beyond plain sheets—it now mimics slate, tile, or even wood shake.

Style highlights:

  • Asphalt roofs: Available in 3-tab, architectural, and premium designs

  • Metal roofs: Offered in standing seam, corrugated, and stamped panels

  • Both materials adapt easily to most roof pitches and layouts

Thanks to new finishes and color coatings, metal roofs can now achieve almost any aesthetic you want.

👉 Reference: HGTV – Roof Design Trends

Color and Finish Options

Color selection plays a huge role in exterior harmony. Asphalt roofs generally offer warmer tones—browns, reds, and grays—while metal roofs include cooler shades such as silver, blue, or green.

Key differences:

  • Asphalt’s matte finish blends naturally with siding and brick

  • Metal’s glossy or textured finish reflects light beautifully

  • Both enhance visual balance when paired with the right trim or fascia

Ultimately, your home’s architectural style should guide your color and texture choice for maximum curb appeal.

👉 Reference: Better Homes & Gardens – Roof Color Guide

Matching Roofs to Home Styles

When comparing asphalt vs metal roofs, design compatibility is essential. Asphalt complements classic suburban homes, while metal fits better with modern or farmhouse-inspired builds.

Perfect pairings:

  • Colonial homes: Asphalt shingles add traditional charm

  • Modern houses: Sleek standing seam metal roofs create clean lines

  • Farmhouses: Corrugated metal delivers rustic appeal

Therefore, material choice can emphasize your home’s personality and regional character.

👉 Reference: Architectural Digest – Home Exteriors

Aesthetic Comparison: Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Explore which roofing material fits your style and visual goals.

Design Variety

Asphalt Roofs: Excellent (many styles)
Metal Roofs: Excellent (modern textures & shapes)

Color Options

Asphalt Roofs: Warm, natural tones
Metal Roofs: Wide range, reflective finishes

Style Compatibility

Asphalt Roofs: Best for classic homes
Metal Roofs: Ideal for modern/farmhouse designs

Fade Resistance

Asphalt Roofs: Moderate
Metal Roofs: Very high

Visual Lifespan

Asphalt Roofs: 10–20 years
Metal Roofs: 40+ years

🎨 The look of your roof is part of your home's personality—choose wisely!

Weather Resistance – Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

When it comes to protection against the elements, asphalt vs metal roofs perform very differently. Tennessee’s climate brings heavy rain, strong winds, and seasonal temperature shifts—so weather resistance becomes a crucial factor when choosing a roofing system.

How Asphalt vs Metal Roofs Handle Rain and Moisture

Moisture is one of the biggest threats to roofing materials. Asphalt shingles, though reliable, can absorb small amounts of water over time, leading to rot or mold. In contrast, metal roofs naturally shed water thanks to smooth surfaces and overlapping seams.

Rain performance comparison:

  • Asphalt roofs: May absorb moisture through small cracks

  • Metal roofs: Channel rain efficiently and prevent pooling

  • Both: Benefit from proper gutter systems and roof slope

Therefore, in regions with frequent rain, metal provides superior long-term moisture protection.

👉 Reference: National Roofing Contractors Association – Roof Drainage

Wind Resistance and Storm Performance

Wind resistance separates asphalt vs metal roofs even more. While modern asphalt shingles are rated for up to 130 mph winds, metal panels can handle gusts of 140–160 mph when properly fastened.

Storm advantages:

  • Asphalt roofs may lift during high winds if edges are loose

  • Metal roofs interlock tightly, resisting uplift

  • Reinforced fasteners improve performance for both types

As a result, metal roofing tends to outperform asphalt in areas prone to storms or tornadoes.

👉 Reference: FEMA – Roofing and Wind Safety

Fire and Hail Resistance

Fire resistance is another essential factor. Asphalt shingles can burn when exposed to prolonged flames, while metal roofs are completely non-combustible. Similarly, during hailstorms, metal roofs resist denting and cracking far better than asphalt.

Safety features:

  • Asphalt roofs: Class A fire rating with underlayment

  • Metal roofs: Fully fire-resistant, ideal for wildfire-prone areas

  • Hail resistance: Metal panels resist impact without splitting

These features make metal an excellent choice for homeowners focused on durability and safety.

👉 Reference: UL Solutions – Fire Ratings for Roofing Materials

Performance in Temperature Extremes

Temperature fluctuations can cause roofing materials to expand and contract. Asphalt shingles often crack under extreme heat or cold, whereas metal roofs adapt smoothly without damage.

Temperature performance:

  • Asphalt roofs: Vulnerable to thermal cracking

  • Metal roofs: Expand uniformly without breaking seals

  • Both benefit from reflective coatings and insulation layers

For Tennessee’s mix of hot summers and cold winters, metal roofing offers a clear advantage in climate durability.

Weather Resistance: Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Weather Factor Asphalt Roofs Metal Roofs
Rain Resistance Moderate (can absorb moisture) Excellent (sheds water effectively)
Wind Resistance Up to 130 mph Up to 160 mph
Fire Resistance Class A with protection Fully non-combustible
Hail Resistance Prone to cracking Highly resistant
Temperature Durability May crack in heat/cold cycles Expands evenly, minimal stress

Environmental Impact – Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Sustainability is becoming a top priority for many homeowners. When comparing asphalt vs metal roofs, the environmental footprint can make a major difference. From manufacturing to disposal, every material affects energy use, emissions, and waste differently.

Production and Resource Use

The production process determines much of a roof’s environmental cost. Asphalt shingles are petroleum-based, which means they rely heavily on non-renewable resources. Metal roofing, on the other hand, is often made from recycled steel or aluminum.

Environmental differences:

  • Asphalt roofs: High energy consumption during manufacturing

  • Metal roofs: Up to 95% recycled content in some products

  • Both: Benefit from responsible sourcing and certified suppliers

As a result, metal roofs require less raw material and have a lower carbon footprint overall.

👉 Reference: EPA – Sustainable Building Materials

Roof Longevity and Waste Reduction

Roof longevity directly impacts waste. Asphalt roofs last only 15–25 years, meaning frequent replacements and more landfill waste. In contrast, metal roofs can last 50 years or more and are fully recyclable at the end of their life cycle.

Sustainability comparison:

  • Asphalt: Shorter lifespan, higher waste volume

  • Metal: Long-lasting, 100% recyclable

  • Both: Improve performance with regular maintenance

By choosing a longer-lasting material, homeowners reduce waste and contribute to greener living.

👉 Reference: Green Building Advisor – Roofing Sustainability

Energy Efficiency and Carbon Footprint

Energy efficiency also influences a roof’s environmental impact. Reflective coatings on asphalt vs metal roofs can reduce heat absorption, but metal roofs naturally reflect more sunlight.

Eco-performance overview:

  • Metal roofs: Lower energy demand for cooling

  • Asphalt roofs: Higher heat retention

  • Both: Compatible with solar panel installations

These differences help metal roofing reduce carbon emissions and overall energy usage throughout its lifespan.

👉 Reference: Energy Star – Energy Efficient Roofing

Recyclability and End-of-Life Impact

At the end of their lifespan, disposal methods become critical. Asphalt shingles usually end up in landfills, while metal roofs enter recycling systems.

Recycling details:

  • Asphalt roofs: Often non-recyclable due to tar content

  • Metal roofs: Melted and reused for construction materials

  • Both: Can be repurposed when properly separated

Consequently, choosing metal roofing supports a circular economy and minimizes environmental harm.

Environmental Impact: Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

Compare sustainability, efficiency, and waste factors between roof types.

Manufacturing Energy Use

Asphalt Roofs: High (petroleum-based)
Metal Roofs: Low (recycled materials)

Lifespan and Waste

Asphalt Roofs: 15–25 years, non-recyclable
Metal Roofs: 40–70 years, recyclable

Energy Efficiency

Asphalt Roofs: Moderate
Metal Roofs: Excellent

Carbon Footprint

Asphalt Roofs: Higher
Metal Roofs: Lower

End-of-Life Impact

Asphalt Roofs: Landfill disposal
Metal Roofs: Recyclable, reusable

🌍 Sustainable roofing starts with smart material choices!

Asphalt vs Metal Roofs Services in Johnson City, TN

At Rolando Roofing LLC, we don’t just fix roofs—we specialize in professional Concrete Services in Johnson City, TN. With over 9 years of experience, our team ensures your home is storm-resistant from top to bottom, combining durable materials with unmatched craftsmanship.

Why Choose Rolando Roofing for Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

1. Proven Expertise Across Roofing Systems

Rolando Roofing specializes in both asphalt and metal roof installations. Our trained professionals understand the distinct challenges each material presents. Whether it’s shingle alignment or metal seam sealing, we ensure every detail meets the highest industry standards.

✓ Certified and insured technicians
✓ Experience with residential and commercial roofs
✓ Precision-focused installation for long-lasting results

2. Local Knowledge and Climate Adaptation

Every Tennessee roof faces unique weather conditions. We tailor every project to handle Johnson City’s heavy rains, high humidity, and temperature fluctuations.

✓ Proper attic ventilation
✓ Moisture barriers for local humidity
✓ Reinforcement for seasonal storms

3. Transparent Pricing and Honest Consultations

We provide clear cost estimates, explain material options, and help you make an informed decision between asphalt vs metal roofs without pressure or confusion.

✓ Free, detailed estimates
✓ No hidden fees
✓ Step-by-step guidance

4. Commitment to Quality Materials

We use only top-rated materials sourced from trusted manufacturers. Whether you choose asphalt shingles or metal panels, every product meets strict durability and warranty standards.

✓ Premium-grade materials
✓ Energy-efficient and impact-resistant
✓ Manufacturer warranties

5. Exceptional Customer Care

Customer satisfaction drives everything we do. Our team prioritizes communication, respect, and punctuality on every job. We treat every home as if it were our own.

✓ Friendly, reliable service
✓ Daily updates and clean worksites
✓ Fast response for repairs

6. Comprehensive Roofing Services

Beyond asphalt vs metal roofs, Rolando Roofing offers complete exterior solutions to protect and enhance your home.

✓ Roof installation, repair, and maintenance
✓ Gutter, siding, fascia & soffit services
✓ Drywall, painting, doors & windows

FAQs About Asphalt vs Metal Roofs

What lasts longer — asphalt vs metal roofs?

Metal roofs generally last two to three times longer than asphalt. While asphalt shingles may last 20–25 years, metal roofing can protect your home for 50 years or more with minimal maintenance.

Are asphalt vs metal roofs better for hot climates?

Metal roofs perform better in hot regions because they reflect sunlight and reduce heat absorption. Asphalt roofs tend to trap more heat, which can increase cooling costs during summer months.

Which option is more affordable, asphalt vs metal roofs?

Asphalt roofs cost less upfront, making them budget-friendly for many homeowners. However, metal roofs offer better long-term value due to their durability and energy efficiency.

Do asphalt vs metal roofs need different maintenance routines?

Yes. Asphalt roofs require more frequent inspections and shingle replacements, while metal roofs need periodic checks for fasteners or coatings. Both benefit from annual professional maintenance.

Are asphalt vs metal roofs energy efficient?

Metal roofs are more energy efficient thanks to their reflective surface. They help reduce indoor temperatures, especially in sunny climates, while asphalt roofs absorb and retain more heat.

Which type of roof adds more resale value — asphalt vs metal roofs?

Metal roofs typically increase resale value more because of their long lifespan, low maintenance, and modern appearance. Asphalt roofs still add value but require earlier replacement.

Can I switch from asphalt to a metal roof easily?

Yes, switching is possible with professional help. Contractors usually remove old shingles, inspect the structure, and prepare the decking before installing metal panels for maximum safety.

Which roofing material handles storms better — asphalt vs metal roofs?

Metal roofs outperform asphalt during storms. They resist wind uplift, hail damage, and heavy rain more effectively, making them ideal for Tennessee’s changing weather conditions.

Explore Our Portfolio—See Why We're #1 in TN!

Explore Our Portfolio—See Why We're #1 in TN!